Renting a home is more affordable for most Americans, with about 30% of households renting. This is probably why you already have a life tenant on your property or are considering the option.
The good thing is - this type of resident should manage your property, taking care of it as long as they live in it or until they die. But what happens if a life tenant is not maintaining property?
In this article, we'll discuss life tenancy and tell you about the actions you can take as a property manager.
Let's jump right in!
What Is a Life Tenant?
A life tenant is someone you grant the right to use and occupy your property for the duration of their life. This right is non-transferable and does not equate to ownership of the property itself. Instead, it's a form of interest in the property that only lasts until the life tenant's death.
You set up a life tenant in a legal arrangement called a life estate. It works as follows:
- You create a life estate through a deed or a will.
- The person creating the life estate (often the property owner) specifies who will hold the life estate (the life tenant) and who will receive the property after the life tenant's death (the remaindermen).
- The life tenant can use the property, receive income from it (if applicable), and is responsible for its maintenance and taxes. For instance, they must ensure the property does not deteriorate significantly, which would adversely affect the remaindermen's future interest. Still, they should not make significant alterations or sell the property without the agreement of the remaindermen.
When your life tenant dies, the property passes directly to the remaindermen without going through probate.
What Are the Responsibilities of a Life Tenant?
Here are the key responsibilities of your life resident:
Maintenance and Repairs
Have you ever wondered who pays for maintenance on a rental property? Well, if it's a life tenancy, the resident should keep the property in good repair. This includes routine maintenance such as mowing the lawn, cleaning gutters, and fixing broken fixtures or appliances. They should address any issues that could lead to more significant damage or depreciation of the property over time.
Paying Property Outlay
Life tenants must pay for the regular expenses associated with the property. This includes utility bills, property taxes, and insurance premiums. You avoid legal issues or penalties when they pay real estate taxes promptly.
Compliance With Laws
The life tenant must comply with all local, state, and federal laws on the property. These laws cover building codes, zoning laws, and any regulations specific to the property's location.
Retaining Home Value
A life estate resident should not engage in any activity that could permanently damage the property's value. They must avoid cutting down trees, removing fixtures, or undertaking major renovations that could negatively impact the property's structural integrity or market value.
Insurance
A life tenancy resident should maintain adequate insurance on the property to protect against potential losses from accidents or natural disasters. They should ensure that the insurance coverage is sufficient and up to date.
Respecting Remaindermen's Rights
While life tenants have the right to use the property, they must also respect the future interest of the remaindermen. This means not undertaking any actions that could infringe upon the remaindermen's eventual full ownership and use of the property.
Life Tenant Not Maintaining Property: Initial Steps to Address the Issue
When you notice that a life tenant is not maintaining the property as per the agreement, you want to act fast to address the issue. Here are a few steps to begin with:
1. Communicate Concerns and Expectations to Resident
Start with a direct conversation with the resident to communicate your concerns regarding the state of the property. This is also a good time to remind the life estate resident of their maintenance responsibilities.
Be specific about what maintenance they've neglected and provide a timeline for when they should resolve the issue. This discussion can often prompt the resident to take action without further escalation.
2. Review Life Estate Agreement
If your resident still won't take care of the property, you can review the agreement together. You want to outline the specific responsibilities and duties of the life tenant regarding property maintenance.
Point out the relevant clauses that address property upkeep and discuss any misunderstandings the resident may have about their obligations.
3. Provide Guidance on Documenting the Property's Condition
At this point, encourage your life resident to document the property's condition regularly. We recommend using RentCheck's inspection software, which allows residents to conduct thorough, systematic inspections to capture and report the current state of the property.
The documentation is crucial for both ongoing maintenance and for resolving any disputes that may arise concerning property condition.
The software generates a detailed report, complete with photos, which can be invaluable for comparing the property's condition over time and ensuring compliance with the life estate agreement.
Legal Actions and Mediation Available
You have several legal actions and mediation options available when dealing with a life tenant who is not maintaining the property. For instance
Review and Communicate the Life Estate Agreement:
You can review the life estate agreement to clarify the responsibilities laid out for your life tenant. You want to communicate these responsibilities clearly to the resident, possibly with the help of legal counsel, to underscore the seriousness of the obligations. This is an easy way to encourage compliance without further legal steps.
Mediation
Mediation is a better alternative before moving to litigation, which is costly and time-consuming. You can involve a neutral third party to help everyone reach a mutual agreement.
Legal Actions
Suppose a life tenant still fails to maintain the property, causing deterioration in its condition or value. In this case, you have the right to take legal action as a property manager or remainderman. This can involve filing a petition in court to demand that the life tenant fulfills their maintenance obligations or, in severe cases, evict the life tenant.
The courts can also intervene to prevent the life tenant from performing any activities that might further harm the property's value.
Protective Measures for Remaindermen
As a property manager overseeing a life estate, it's crucial to understand how to protect the interests of remaindermen while managing relationships and property maintenance effectively. Here are some strategic protective measures you can implement:
Clear Documentation
Ensure the life estate agreement is clear and easy to understand and that it specifies the responsibilities of the life tenant concerning property maintenance, taxes, and insurance. Have everything in writing to prevent misunderstandings and provide a legal basis for necessary actions.
Routine Inspections
You can schedule regular property inspections to monitor the property’s condition and ensure compliance with maintenance requirements. This will help you identify issues early and keep the life tenant accountable for their responsibilities.
Financial Oversight
Keep track of the life tenant's compliance with financial obligations, such as paying property taxes and maintaining adequate insurance coverage. This is crucial to prevent legal issues and ensure that the property remains protected under all circumstances.
Legal Preparedness
Be prepared to take legal action if necessary. If the life tenant fails to meet their obligations, understanding the legal steps to enforce compliance or to address severe breaches of the agreement is important. It may include mediation, arbitration, or court proceedings if necessary.
Engage With Remaindermen
Maintain open lines of communication with the remaindermen to ensure they understand the property's status and any issues that arise. Their involvement and consent may be necessary for significant decisions affecting the property, so keeping them informed helps them make seamless decisions.
Long-Term Solutions
When your life tenants don't always take care of your property, it's important to consider several strategies to ensure the property remains in good condition and that all parties' interests are protected. Here are three long-term solutions:
1. Renegotiating Life Estate Terms
Feel like your agreement may need some fine-tuning? Then, it's best to revisit and renegotiate the terms of the life estate deed. This could involve setting more explicit maintenance responsibilities, establishing regular inspection schedules, and clarifying the consequences of non-compliance.
Fair renegotiation ensures that both the life tenant and the remaindermen have clear expectations and responsibilities, which will prevent disputes and ensure the property is maintained to a certain standard.
2. Potential for Life Tenant to Relinquish Rights
In some cases, it may be possible for the life tenant to voluntarily relinquish their rights if they are unable or unwilling to fulfill their maintenance duties. The relinquishing could be in exchange for an alternative arrangement, such as moving to a more manageable property or another form of compensation.
All involved parties, including the remainderman, must agree to this solution.
3. Highlight the Importance of Planning and Preventive Maintenance
Finally, you can educate life tenants on the importance of preventive property maintenance and regular upkeep to avoid larger issues down the road.
You can start by implementing a planned maintenance schedule, perhaps facilitated by a property management company, which would keep the property in good condition. At the same time, the life tenant stays aware of their responsibilities.
Preventive measures maintain the property's value and reduce the likelihood of disputes over its condition.
Get Rental Property Maintenance in Order With RentCheck's Inspection Software
Life tenancy comes with benefits for property managers, residents, and remaindermen. However, problems can arise when your life tenant fails to take good care of the property. In this case, the property would start deteriorating and lose value, which would not benefit the remainderman who inherits it after the current owner's death.
We have discussed the measures you can take when faced with this problem. But you can still make things easier by insisting on regular inspections and reports from your life tenants.
With RentCheck, all your property inspections are a breeze. You will empower your life tenants to perform their own inspections, increasing accuracy while saving time. You will also be able to easily track how well they fulfill their maintenance responsibilities.
Sign up for a free trial today!
